Strategic Admission Behavior and Its Implications: Evidence from a Cardiac Surgery Department

Expand
  • 1 School of Management, Fudan University, Shanghai 200433, China;
    2 School of Economics and Business Administration, Chongqing University, Chongqing 400044, China

Received date: 2020-12-20

  Revised date: 2021-10-06

  Online published: 2023-02-28

Supported by

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 71720107003, 72033003 and 71722008).

Abstract

This paper examines a decentralized admission control system with partial capacity sharing in a hospital setting. The admission decision is made by each physician who is assigned a number of dedicated inpatient beds. A physician can "borrow" beds from other physicians if his dedicated beds are all occupied. We seek to understand the impact of the "borrowing cost" on physicians' admission behavior.We find that(i) If the borrowing cost is low, a physician tends to admit lower-risk patients when either his or others' capacity utilization is higher; (ii) If the borrowing cost is moderate, a physician tends to admit higher (lower)-risk patients when his (others') capacity utilization is higher; and (iii) If the borrowing cost is high, a physician tends to admit higher-risk patients when either his or others' capacity utilization is higher. We then empirically test and validate these findings. Our work demonstrates that when designing strategic admission control systems, it is important to quantify and perhaps then influence the magnitude of the borrowing cost to induce a proper level of competition without sacrificing the benefit of resource pooling.

Cite this article

Yan-Ying Zhao, Pei-Wen Yu, Jian-Qiang Hu . Strategic Admission Behavior and Its Implications: Evidence from a Cardiac Surgery Department[J]. Journal of the Operations Research Society of China, 2023 , 11(1) : 29 -50 . DOI: 10.1007/s40305-021-00377-2

References

[1] National Statistics Bureau:National Bureau of Statistics of China 2015.National Bureau of Statistics, Beijing (2016)
[2] Shanghai Statistical Bureau:Shanghai Statistical Yearbook 2017.Shanghai Statistical Bureau, Shanghai (2017)
[3] Bekker, R., Koeleman, P.M.:Scheduling admissions and reducing variability in bed demand.Health Care Manag.Sci.14(3), 237(2011)
[4] Monks, T., Worthington, D., Allen, M., Pitt, M., Stein, K., James, M.A.:A modelling tool for capacity planning in acute and community stroke services.BMC Health Serv.Res.16(1), 530(2016)
[5] MacStravic, R.E.S.:Admissions scheduling and capacity pooling:minimizing hospital bed requirements.Inquiry 18(4), 345-350(1981)
[6] Teixeira, A., De Oliveira, M.:Operations research on hospital admission systems:a first overview of the 2005-2014 decade.J.Phys.Conf.Ser.616, 012009(2015)
[7] Dranove, D.:Demand inducement and the physician/patient relationship.Econ.Inq.26(2), 281-298(1988)
[8] Yip, W.C.:Physician response to medicare fee reductions:changes in the volume of coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgeries in the medicare and private sectors.J.Health Econ.17(6), 675-699(1998)
[9] Shmueli, A., Sprung, C.L., Kaplan, E.H.:Optimizing admissions to an intensive care unit.Health Care Manag.Sci.6(3), 131-136(2003)
[10] Kim, S.H., Tong, J., Peden, C.:Admission control biases in hospital unit capacity management:how occupancy information hurdles and decision noise impact utilization.Manag.Sci.66(11), 5151-5170(2020)
[11] Kolesar, P.:A Markovian model for hospital admission scheduling.Manag.Sci.16(6), B-84(1970)
[12] Powell, A., Savin, S., Savva, N.:Physician workload and hospital reimbursement:overworked physicians generate less revenue per patient.Manuf.Serv.Oper.Manag.14(4), 512-528(2012)
[13] Freeman, M., Savva, N., Scholtes, S.:Gatekeepers at work:an empirical analysis of a maternity unit.Manag.Sci.63(10), 3147-3167(2016)
[14] Kc, D.S., Terwiesch, C.:Impact of workload on service time and patient safety:an econometric analysis of hospital operations.Manag.Sci.55(9), 1486-1498(2009)
[15] Jack, E.P., Powers, T.L.:A review and synthesis of demand management, capacity management and performance in health-care services.Int.J.Manag.Rev.11(2), 149-174(2009)
[16] Kumar, A., Ow, P.S., Prietula, M.J.:Organizational simulation and information systems design:an operations level example.Manag.Sci.39(2), 218-240(1993)
[17] Green, L.:Queueing analysis in healthcare.In:Patient Flow:Reducing Delay in Healthcare Delivery, pp.281-307.Springer, New York (2006)
[18] Gedik, R., Zhang, S., Rainwater, C.:Strategic level proton therapy patient admission planning:a Markov decision process modeling approach.Health Care Manag.Sci.20(2), 286-302(2017)
[19] Tsai, P.F., Lin, F.M.:An application of multi-attribute value theory to patient-bed assignment in hospital admission management:an empirical study.J.Healthc.Eng.5(4), 439-456(2014)
[20] Kim, S.H., Chan, C.W., Olivares, M., Escobar, G.:ICU admission control:an empirical study of capacity allocation and its implication for patient outcomes.Manag.Sci.61(1), 19-38(2014)
[21] Park, S., Lee, J., Ikai, H., Otsubo, T., Imanaka, Y.:Decentralization and centralization of healthcare resources:investigating the associations of hospital competition and number of cardiologists per hospital with mortality and resource utilization in Japan.Health Policy 113(1-2), 100-109(2013)
[22] Song, H., Tucker, A.L., Murrell, K.L.:The diseconomies of queue pooling:an empirical investigation of emergency department length of stay.Manag.Sci.61(12), 3032-3053(2015)
[23] Hackman, J.R., Oldham, G.R.:Motivation through the design of work:test of a theory.Organ.Behav.Hum.Perform.16(2), 250-279(1976)
[24] Cavalieri, M., Ferrante, L.:Does fiscal decentralization improve health outcomes? Evidence from infant mortality in Italy.Soc.Sci.Med.164, 74-88(2016)
[25] Lin, K.Y.:Decentralized admission control of a queueing system:a game-theoretic model.Naval Res.Logist.(NRL) 50(7), 702-718(2003)
[26] Dong, J., Shi, P., Zheng, F., Jin, X.:Off-service placement in inpatient ward network:resource pooling versus service slowdown.Columbia Business School Research Paper Forthcoming (2019)
[27] Song, H., Tucker, A., Graue, R., Moravick, S., Yang, J.:Capacity pooling in hospitals:the hidden consequences of off-service placement.Manag.Sci.66(9), 3825-3842(2020)
[28] Dai, J., Shi, P.:Inpatient overflow:an approximate dynamic programming approach.Manuf.Serv.Oper.Manag.21(4), 894-911(2019)
[29] Aumann, R.J., Hart, S.:Handbook of Game Theory with Economic Applications.Elsevier, NorthHolland (2002)
[30] General Office of the Ministry of Health:Notice of the general office of the ministry of health on printing and distributing the measures for surgery grading administration in medical institutions (trial).http://www.nhc.gov.cn/wjw/ywfw/201306/def185b8d52e48918cf7e12e43e956d6.shtml (2013).Accessed 1 Oct 2021
[31] Chinese Burn Association and others:Expert consensus on classification evaluation methods of burn surgery in China (2019 version).Chin.J.Burns 35(11), 769-771(2019)
[32] Hu,J.,Su,Q.,Wang,Q.,Wang,Q.:Asurgeryschedulingmodelbasedonsurgerygradingmanagement system.In:2017 International Conference on Service Systems and Service Management, pp.1-4(2017)
[33] Horn, S.D., Horn, R.A.:Reliability and validity of the severity of illness index.Med.Care 24(2), 159-178(1986)
[34] Brewster,A.C.,Jacobs,C.M.,Bradbury,R.C.:Classifyingseverityofillnessbyusingclinicalfindings.Health Care Financ.Rev.1984(Suppl), 107-108(1984)
[35] Horn, S.D., Horn, R.A., Sharkey, P.D., Chambers, A.F.:Severity of illness within DRGs:homogeneity study.Med.Care 24(3), 225-235(1986)
[36] Brewster, A.C., Karlin, B.G., Hyde, L.A., Jacobs, C.M., Bradbury, R.C., Chae, Y.M.:Medisgrps®:a clinically based approach to classifying hospital patients at admission.Inquiry 22(4), 377-387(1985)
[37] Lyandres, E., Fu, F., Li, E.X.:Do underwriters compete in IPO pricing? Manag.Sci.64(2), 925-954(2018)
[38] Huckman, R.S., Pisano, G.P.:The firm specificity of individual performance:evidence from cardiac surgery.Manag.Sci.52(4), 473-488(2006)
Options
Outlines

/